Isabella: Braveheart of France by Colin Falconer
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
Starting with her marriage to Edward II of England at the age of twelve, ‘Isabella: Braveheart of France’ follows the life of Isabella Queen of England, 1295-1358, (best known for her moniker of the She-Wolf of France) up until the death of her husband. The young princess hopes that the marriage will provide her with a gallant, knight for a husband that will love her unwaveringly, instead she is thrust into a thick political landscape which relies on her as though she were queen in her own right. Intrigue, infidelity, war, rebellion, and jealousy, all in the day’s work of being Queen.
I really enjoyed reading this. The writing is simple, in third person and the present tense, and the chapters are short making this a very easy read – I finished it in two days. The action closely follows Isabella’s perspective; although it may be argued that this is one sided (I’m not closed to suggestion that Falconer may have benefited from multiple perspectives similar to Conn Iggulden if only for the sake of dramatic irony) the focus makes Isabella accessible to anyone who does not know much about her. It gives a strong account of her thoughts and feelings, and as a historical female protagonist she is written as a woman of her time who understands what is expected -unfairly or not- of her gender both within medieval society, and as a Queen; all thankfully without modern hindsights of equality that some historical fiction writers fall in to. It was a refreshing change for such a human approach to her when Isabella is frequently written either as a weak and weary wronged wife, or a notorious bitch who is ferociously ambitious. Likewise Edward II is given the same treatment; he’s not his typical role of either arrogant and abusive husband or a foppish homosexual, though you will groan with frustration at his inability to ‘king up’ it is impossible not to sympathise with his struggles, both of existing outside of the medieval sexual norm and for being an individual not designed to be a king but thrust into the role regardless.
My only quibble is that the book would have benefited from a little extra editing. Though I did not notice any obvious typos, I was aware that the author was repetitive with their vocabulary. For example, roughly halfway through a character is described as ‘obsequious, a few pages later the same is said again, and again a few pages later, as though the author had just learnt the word and felt the need to use the new knowledge. Also sometimes it was difficult to tell who was speaking in a long block of dialogue, especially if there was more than two characters, as Falconer doesn’t use way-pointing ‘he said’ or ‘she said’.
I’ll admit I initially worried this would be a cheesy take on history (especially after the whole ‘Braveheart’ thing) but it’s not and I really enjoyed reading this. If you prefer your historical novels to not be trite and melodramatic, or violent gorenography, then I would definitely recommend this book. However, if you are looking for a Guinevere and Lancelot style story about Isabella and Mortimer then this is probably not for you.
Content warnings: Infrequent swearing, infrequent non-explicit sex scenes.
Isabella: Braveheart of France by Colin Falconer, Paperback £8.99, also available in audio and ebook formats.
Disclaimer: I was provided with a free Kindle edition by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
View all my reviews